RateMyPlacement and RateMyApprenticeship are now Higherin: Learn More

Mechanical Project Coordinator Review

at BAT

Placement (10 Months+)

Manufacturing

Southampton

Review Submitted: August 2026

Overall Rating

2.7 /5

The Overall Rating is the average of all the ratings given in each category. We take those individual ratings and combine them into one final score!

5/5 - Overview of Role
2.5/5 - Skills Development
1/5 - Support and Guidance
3.3/5 - Company Culture
3/5 - Overall Experience
2/5 - Future Career Prospects

Overview of Role

Please give an overview of your role and what this involves on a day-to-day basis.

I joined BAT as a Manufacturing Engineering Intern within Manufacturing Innovation. My role covered a mix of mechanical design, automation, software development and process improvement work within the Southampton manufacturing site. On a day-to-day basis, I worked on engineering projects linked to manufacturing equipment, built Python tools to automate manual processes, analysed production-related problems and spoke with technicians, engineers and other teams to understand where improvements could be made. Over the course of the placement, I worked across both hardware and software, which was one of the most valuable parts of the experience.

Were you given much responsibility during your placement / internship?

I would separate the responsibility I was given from the responsibility I had to create for myself. When I found or created a project, I was trusted with a high level of ownership and was able to lead work independently, engage stakeholders, develop technical solutions and present outcomes. This included two internal applications that were published and used within the business, as well as an engineering concept that progressed towards patenting. However, meaningful responsibility was not consistently built into the placement structure. A lot of my best learning came from independently approaching teams, identifying problems and creating projects myself. While that helped me become more proactive and independent, I think this is a weakness for students early in their careers who are looking for a steep learning curve. BAT offers autonomy, but in my experience, the placement does not consistently provide enough structured project work or direction unless you actively create those opportunities yourself.

Please rate how meaningful the work you were doing was

5/5

Skills Development

Have you learnt any new skills, or developed your existing skills?

Yes. I developed significantly across both technical and personal skills, although a lot of that development came through independent learning and taking initiative rather than through formal training.
Technically, I improved my mechanical design, CAD, prototyping and manufacturing problem-solving skills. I also developed much stronger software and automation skills, particularly through building Python tools, working on computer vision/inspection automation and creating applications to replace manual workflows. Before the placement, I had used programming mostly in an academic context, but during the year I learnt how to apply it to real manufacturing problems where the output had to be practical, usable and reliable.
I also developed a much better understanding of manufacturing processes, factory operations, stakeholder requirements and the practical constraints that affect engineering decisions. One of the most valuable lessons was learning that a technically good solution is not enough. It also needs to be usable by technicians and operators, fit into existing processes and solve a problem that actually matters.
On the personal side, I became much more proactive, independent and confident. After the Fit2Win restructuring changed the scope of my original work, I had to approach different teams, identify opportunities and create meaningful projects myself. That developed my communication, stakeholder management, resilience and ability to work with ambiguity.

How would you rate the training provided during your experience?

1/5

How would you rate your development of industry-specific skills during the experience?

2/5

How would you rate your development of personal / soft skills during the experience?

4/5

Please rate how these skills have helped you in your career development

3/5

Support and Guidance

How much support and guidance did you receive during your placement / internship?

I received support from individuals across the business when I actively reached out, and many people were generous with their time once I approached them. This helped me learn a lot and gave me access to different teams and projects.
However, the overall support and guidance was inconsistent, particularly after Fit2Win changed the scope of my original placement. There were periods where the direction of my role became unclear and I felt that I had to navigate the situation quite independently. Rather than having a clear replacement structure or project pipeline, I often had to identify opportunities myself by speaking to different teams and finding areas where I could contribute.
In hindsight, that helped me develop independence and confidence, but I also think more structured guidance would have improved the placement experience. This was especially important because placement students are still early in their careers and may not always know how to navigate a large organisation when their original role changes.

How would you rate the support and guidance from your line manager?

1/5

How would you rate the support and guidance from the wider team?

1/5

Company Culture

What was the company culture and general atmosphere like?

The company culture at BAT was generally welcoming, professional and supportive. As a placement student, I found people across the business approachable and willing to give their time, whether that was to explain their work, offer advice or help me understand where I could contribute.
One of the things I appreciated most was that I felt able to speak to people outside my immediate team. This was especially valuable when the scope of my placement changed, as it allowed me to reach out to different functions, learn more about the wider business and find opportunities to get involved in meaningful projects.
The atmosphere was also quite open in the sense that, once I showed initiative, people were generally receptive to my ideas and trusted me to take ownership. That gave me the confidence to lead projects independently and develop solutions that could have a real impact.

How would you rate the inclusiveness of the culture?

3/5

How would you rate the social opportunities?

3/5

How would you rate the diversity initiatives?

4/5

How would you rate the charity, sustainability and corporate social responsibility (CSR) initiatives?

3/5

Overall Experience

To what extent did you enjoy your placement / internship?

I had a mixed experience overall. I valued the autonomy and was proud of the work I delivered, particularly the two internal applications used within the business and the engineering concept that progressed towards patenting. However, the placement was not consistently structured, and meaningful work was not always readily available. A lot of the value came from me actively finding problems, approaching teams and creating projects myself, rather than from a clear placement pathway. This helped me become more proactive and independent, but it also made the experience frustrating at times, especially as someone looking for a steep learning curve early in my career.

Please rate your level of enjoyment on your placement / internship

4/5

Please rate how your experience met your expectations

2/5

Recommendations & Advice

Would you recommend BAT to a friend?

No

What advice would you give to others applying to BAT

I would advise future applicants to be proactive from the start. BAT is a large organisation with many interesting problems to solve, but the best opportunities are not always handed to you directly. Most or all valuable parts of my placement came from approaching different teams, asking questions and creating projects outside my original scope.
I would also recommend clarifying return routes and graduate programme eligibility early. In my experience, communication around the Global Graduate route was disappointing, as changes to eligibility and strategic direction were communicated very late in the placement. Applicants should ask early which programmes they are eligible for, what degree backgrounds are being considered and whether any business changes could affect their options.
Overall, BAT can offer strong autonomy and real project ownership, but you need to take responsibility for shaping your own placement and getting clarity on future opportunities.

Future Career Prospects

Please rate the future employment prospects at BAT

2/5

Did you receive an offer to return as a graduate?

No
In This Review
Join Now

Join the Higherin Community

Save Time

Easily add jobs from Higherin or external platforms to keep everything organised.

Personalised Alerts

Get tailored job recommendations and updates straight to your inbox.

Exclusive Features

Access tools like application tracking, deadline reminders, and saved searches.

Stay Ahead

Be the first to know about the latest opportunities and deadlines.

Completely Free

Create an account and unlock powerful features at no cost.